Clarence Valley Council Suspended

news story(24)

Clarence Valley Council has officially been suspended for three months, with the NSW Government appointing John Rayner PSM as interim administrator, replacing the decision-making authority of all nine elected councillors.

NSW Minister for Local Government Ron Hoenig signed the suspension order on Thursday, 15 October 2026, under section 438I of the Local Government Act 1993. The order was published in the NSW Government Gazette the same day, bringing the suspension into effect.

In the order, Mr Hoenig stated he reasonably believed the appointment of an interim administrator was necessary to restore the proper and effective functioning of Clarence Valley Council.

The decision follows weeks of turmoil within Council, including the termination of former General Manager Laura Black’s contract, changes in Council leadership and ongoing concerns about governance and administration.

The suspension has prompted mixed reactions across the Clarence Valley. While some residents who have been calling for intervention have welcomed the decision, others have expressed concern about what it means for the future of Council and the loss of locally elected representation.

For some, the appointment of an administrator represents an opportunity to address longstanding governance concerns. For others, it raises questions about accountability, community representation and what happens when the three-month suspension ends.

Earlier this month, councillors unanimously requested an independent investigation into Council’s governance, administration, operations and financial management dating back to January 2022.

Following that resolution, the Minister notified Council he was considering suspension and provided councillors with an opportunity to respond.

At an extraordinary meeting on 6 October, councillors resolved to seek an experienced interim General Manager to develop and implement an improvement plan. However, the proposed measures did not prevent the suspension.

Mr Rayner has extensive experience in NSW local government, including previous roles as administrator of Georges River Council, Acting General Manager of Armidale Regional Council and General Manager of Sutherland Shire Council.

In 2024, he was appointed by Minister Hoenig to oversee the New England Weeds Authority following financial and governance concerns.

Councillors respond

Peter Johnstone, who was elected Mayor less than a month ago, expressed disappointment at the decision, particularly the loss of elected representation.

“I came into the role of Mayor less than a month ago with a clear agenda and a strong commitment to delivering positive outcomes for our community,” Mr Johnstone said.

“Most of all, I am frustrated that local democracy has been put on hold. Regardless of individual views about Council, decisions affecting the Clarence Valley should ultimately be made by representatives elected by our community.”

Councillor Lynne Cairns acknowledged concerns about the loss of local democracy but said the suspension could provide an opportunity to address longstanding governance issues.

Reflecting on her two years as a councillor, Ms Cairns described what she believed to be dysfunction within Council’s administration and governance, along with strained relationships between councillors.

She also expressed disappointment with an Office of Local Government fact-finding exercise conducted in November 2025, saying she believed a more thorough investigation was warranted.

Ms Cairns said she hoped Mr Rayner’s appointment would lead to an impartial investigation and help put Council back on track.

Long-serving Councillor Karen Toms, who has represented the Clarence Valley for 18 years, welcomed the administrator’s appointment and said she respected the Minister’s decision.

“I sincerely hope this period also provides an opportunity for the circumstances that brought Council to this point to be independently and thoroughly examined,” Ms Toms said.

She expressed hope that the administration period would restore community confidence and provide stability for Council staff.

Before the suspension was announced, Clarence MP Richie Williamson told Clarence Valley Community Information on 9 October that he was aware of the Minister’s proposed intervention but would not take a position on whether councillors should remain in office.

Mr Williamson said the matter was for the Minister and the appropriate statutory processes to determine, while committing to monitor developments and advocate for the Clarence Valley community.

What happens next?

Although the elected councillors have been suspended, Clarence Valley Council itself has not been shut down.

Council services, including waste collection, road maintenance, libraries, development assessments and other day-to-day operations, can continue.

The significant change is who makes decisions on behalf of the community.

During the suspension, John Rayner will exercise the powers and responsibilities normally held by the elected governing body, including decisions that would ordinarily require a vote of councillors.

The nine councillors cannot exercise their official functions or receive councillor remuneration during this period.

Council meetings can continue under the administrator, and residents can still contact Council, lodge requests, make submissions and participate in consultation processes.

The suspension also does not automatically affect the employment of Council staff or senior management.

The three-month suspension is expected to conclude in January 2027, unless further action is taken under the Local Government Act.

Before the suspension ends, the administrator must provide a report to the Minister. The Minister may then consider whether councillors should resume their duties or whether further intervention is necessary.

Under the legislation, a suspension can be extended once for up to a further three months, subject to the required process.

One significant question remains unanswered: whether the independent investigation originally requested by councillors will proceed.

While Councillors Cairns and Toms have expressed hopes for a thorough investigation, the suspension order does not specifically direct Mr Rayner to conduct one.

It also remains unclear what immediate priorities the administrator will establish or whether changes to Council’s management and governance arrangements will follow.

With the elected councillors suspended and John Rayner now responsible for Council’s governing decisions, the next three months will be closely watched by a community divided between hopes for meaningful change and concerns about the future of local democracy.

1 thought on “Clarence Valley Council Suspended”

  1. Gary Sharplin

    An administrator creates a clean slate approach. Ructions within the CVC have to be sorted in order to trust the body to make proper decisions that reflect ratepayers wishes and expectations. Your organisation’s employers are the ratepayers ! The rates are quickly becoming unaffordable and people are asking about value for monies paid.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top